メイン掲示板


  投稿 ┃ツリー ┃トピック ┃番号順 ┃検索 ┃設定  
4159 / 4551 ツリー ←次へ | 前へ→

【781】■or/otherwise? M.Hoshi 05/4/2(土) 質問

【793】Re:or/otherwise? 管理人 05/4/4(月)

【793】Re:or/otherwise?
 管理人  - 05/4/4(月) -

引用する
パスワード
   ▼M.Hoshiさん:
アメリカのプロの作家のMLで、以下の2文のどっちが正しいか聞いてみました。とりあえず、その答えを投稿しておきます。

> (1) He must have done his best, or he would have failed.
> (2) He must have done his best, otherwise he would have failed.

I'd say, technically, they're both grammatically correct, but the second one
is clearer than the first one. OR tends to imply that either the first part
occured OR the second part occured. In your example, it's more like UNLESS
the first part occured, the second part could not have occured.

I would also say the punctuation of the second one should be
"He must have done his best; otherwise, he would have failed."

  投稿 ┃ツリー ┃トピック ┃番号順 ┃検索 ┃設定  
4159 / 4551 ツリー ←次へ | 前へ→
ページ:  ┃  記事番号:   
196,992
(SS)C-BOARD v3.8 is Free